Ultimately, the decision rests on your comfort level with Google’s self-corrections and your own readiness to engage with its tools more manually. Be certain about which domains you place on that disavow list, and ensure they truly qualify as ‘toxic’ and detrimental to your site’s health.
In the ever-evolving world of SEO, staying informed and adaptable is crucial. Whether you choose to lean on Google’s prowess or take matters into your own hands, remember that maintaining a healthy link profile is part of the SEO journey.
After all, isn’t that journey about continually learning and refining your strategy? So, to disavow or not—it’s a choice best made with knowledge and context in hand.